Sandstone bands, mudstone and fill
The city stands on the Coal Measures, a layer cake of sandstones that can pass water and mudstones and shales that hardly pass any. A trial pit that lands in a sandstone band can give a good result; one that lands in shale a short walk away can fail outright. That is why a Sheffield soakaway is sized from tests on that plot, never from what worked next door.
Along the Don and through the old works districts the top few metres are often fill: slag, ash, brick and the footings of demolished sheds. Engineers rarely send water into ground like that, so those sites usually end up with a sealed tank and a controlled outfall instead. Infiltration tends to belong to the suburbs, on natural ground.


