Why not just puddle the local clay?
Glacial till looks like it should hold water, and in places it does. But it is a mix of clay, sand lenses and boulders laid down unevenly by ice, and a pond cut into it can find a sandy seam and drain through it. Puddling clay by hand is slow and hard to check.
A GCL is sodium bentonite locked between two geotextile sheets at the factory, so its thickness is the same everywhere. Wetted once it is buried, the clay expands into a near-watertight layer, and it presses into small punctures if a root or stone finds the liner later. The pond still has a clay bed, which suits planting and wildlife.


